Foreign Affairs - Official Blog
Posts from December 2009

Congressman Don Manzullo (R-IL) today issued the following statement reacting to President Obama’s decision to move up to 210 al Qaeda and Taliban terrorists from Guantanamo Bay to the Thomson Correctional Center in northwest Illinois.


"I've always supported opening the Thomson Correctional Center as a full-fledged state or federal prison because it would provide needed jobs for residents of the region; however, I continue to have serious reservations about moving Guantanamo Bay terrorists to Thomson.

“When I first learned of the proposed transfer of the terrorists, I set out to discover the security impact of moving Guantanamo Bay to the United States – not closing its operations, but moving it to a new location. My primary objective has always been to protect the people I represent. I never believed these terrorists could escape from Thomson, but my concern – shared by Democratic Senator Jim Webb of Virginia., Independent Senator Joe Lieberman of Connecticut, and former Democratic Governor Kathleen Sebelius of Kansas, who fought President Obama and succeeded in keeping Guantanamo from moving to Fort Leavenworth – is that the hatred the terrorists have toward Guantanamo would transfer to Thomson, Illinois, thus creating a magnet for terrorist activity.

“I received an in-depth briefing from the top architect of the plan – Phillip Carter from the Department of Defense (DoD) – who confirmed Thomson would become the largest concentration of incarcerated terrorists in the United States. Mr. Carter agreed with me there would be an increased security risk to northwest Illinois, but he had no way of estimating the extent of this threat. He said, however, he was confident that federal and local law enforcement officials could ‘manage the risk.’ I was shocked, because if there was no way to measure the threat, then how could it be ‘managed.’ He advised he would make available others at DoD for further briefings. I sought more information from DoD, only to discover that Mr. Carter had immediately resigned a few days after he briefed me. DoD refused further briefings for 11 days, and I learned little new at a second briefing.

“The White House said in a statement today: ‘Closing the detention center at Guantanamo is essential to protecting our national security and helping our troops by removing a deadly recruiting tool from the hands of al Qaeda.’ It’s that hatred that I’m concerned will transfer to Thomson. The American people have a right to know the impact of moving Guantanamo’s operations to U.S. soil. Unfortunately, that information will never be known because on Thursday, December 11, language was inserted into a 1,300 page ‘omnibus’ spending bill to keep any information on the issue ‘classified,’ available only to Members of Congress, who cannot share its contents. There is enough unclassified information to release to the public without compromising sources or security, such as the stunning article that appeared in the ­Washington Post on November 29th which investigated the story of Yemeni Arif Rahim, whose brother, Uthman, has been detained at Guantanamo Bay for 8 years for attacking the USS Cole. Consider this passage in the story:

“Arif said he was confident that Obama would close Guantanamo next year. If he doesn’t, or if Utham and other detainees are sent to a prison in the US, many families would consider it an ever greater betrayal. ‘The families, their friends, their tribesmen will have more hatred for the United States,’ Arif said. ‘And perhaps they will consider taking the same path as the extremists.’

“I also inquired of several other agencies, trying to assess the impact these terrorists would have on American courts, but I had to turn to other sources. I discovered, not surprisingly, that the detainees will obtain new constitutional rights once they set foot on American soil, especially the ones to be housed at Thomson because they would be incarcerated permanently with no trial at all. In fact, the terrorists were originally sent to Guantanamo because the US needed not only a secure and impenetrable facility, but one off shore that limited constitutional rights because of dealing with the ‘military combatants.’ One only needs to consider the trial about to take place in federal court in New York City of Khalid Sheik Mohamamed to observe he is receiving more rights than a military tribunal in Guantanamo. I believe the people I represent need to know the impact on the federal courthouse in Rockford, whether trials would be held there as lawyers work to assure them they are entitled to a trial. Even the Obama Administration says holding these terrorists without trial ‘is a gray area.’

“Because the decision to move Gitmo to Thomson has already been made, I’ll press every level of the federal government to enhance the security of the people of this area in order to protect their families, critical workplaces, infrastructure, and schools. And, in addition to continuing to work with Senator Durbin, I’ll bring to the attention of the President, the Governor, and Senator Burris the fact that northwest Illinois needs continued help on economic development, such as prioritizing the widening of U.S. Route 30 in Whiteside County and the last link of our interstate highway system, U.S. Route 20 from Freeport to Galena.”


WASHINGTON, D.C. – Rep. Dan Burton (R-IN-05), Ranking Member of the Foreign Affairs' Subcommittee on the Middle East and South Asia, is an original cosponsor of H.R. 2194, the Iran Refined Petroleum Sanctions Act of 2009. Rep. Burton issued the following statement on the passage of the bill this evening:

"Iran is developing a nuclear weapons system. As many reputable news sources have stated, Iran is extremely close to creating a nuclear bomb. Year after year, we wait for Iran to listen to the international community and open up their nuclear programs, but all they give are a variety of excuses and all sorts of chicanery. Through all the back and forth, the indisputable fact is that they continue their aggressive pursuit of nuclear weapons.

"Furthermore, Iran's nuclear pursuits move forward as their President, Mahmoud Ahmedinejad, has been saying he wants to wipe Israel off the face of the earth. He has rattled a saber of serious proportions, and continually threatens to engulf the Middle East in a devastating crisis. Such a crisis would extend to our shores, particularly in an economic way, since we continue to rely so heavily on oil from the Middle East. In order to avoid a catastrophe, we must apply real pressure on Iran through more serious sanctions.

"Even though I wanted this legislation voted on long ago, I'm grateful that the House finally passed H.R. 2194 today. Instead of standing idly by and hoping for the best, the House, by an overwhelming majority, has chosen to send a clear response to the many threats and nuclear weapons activities that the Iranian government has engaged in for years."


Rep. Burton filed a discharge petition on July 15, 2009, in an effort to force a vote on the the Iran Refined Petroleum Sanctions Act.

Latest Statements
Posts by Subcommittee
Connect with Us
Blog Archives